Lawyers talk land rights

Aboriginal rights lawyers were in Hazelton last week to discuss two cases which could influence how First Nations approach land claims.

Gitxsan hereditary chiefs are divided over whether to launch an aboriginal title claim that capitalizes on a 2014 landmark ruling by the Supreme Court of Canada.

Aboriginal rights lawyers Louise Mandell and Bertha Joseph were in Hazelton last week to deliver a presentation about two court cases which could influence how the Gitxsan and Wet’suwet’en proceed with land rights claims.

The Delgamuukw decision, made by the Supreme Court of Canada in 1997, was a landmark case which determined that aboriginal title did exist.

Led by Gitxsan chief Delgamuukw, whose English name is Earl Muldoe, the case pertained to Gitxsan and Wet’suwet’en territories.

In June last year, a Supreme Court case involving the Tsilhqot’in Nation determined aboriginal Canadians still owned their traditional land unless they had waived that ownership in a treaty with the government.

Both cases were outlined in detail at last week’s meeting, which was attended by about 200 people including Gitxsan and Wet’suwet’en chiefs.

Although the Delgamuukw decision gave First Nations the capacity to negotiate treaty deals, the Tsilhqot’in decision ruled that aboriginal groups would waive their inherent ownership of the land by signing a treaty.

A group of hereditary chiefs known as the Gitxsan United Chiefs, who oppose the signing of any treaty, believe their aboriginal title claim should rest on the findings of the Tsilhqot’in decision.

They believe a treaty deal would sign away the ownership that the Tsilhqot’in ruling awards them.

Hereditary chief Guuhadakw (Norman Stephens) said negotiating a treaty after last year’s Supreme Court decision would be “ludicrous.”

He and the GUC are rallying support to launch a title claim that capitalizes on that ruling.

“After the Tsilhqot’in decision we had all assumed that the nation would be chomping at the bit to actually get back into court and it seemed to be taking a little too long,” he said.

“With the Gitxsan Treaty Society pushing for treaty negotiations we started to get very concerned that the momentum has been lost from the Tsilhqot’in decision.

“The Tsilhqot’in decision brings us so close to getting the title issues settled that to do nothing is to do an injustice to our ancestors.”

He said there were “things that are in progress right now that would lead to a title launch,” but would not provide more detail.

If there was enough support to launch a claim, estimating and securing finances would be the next step, Guuhadakw added.

“Most people consider the Gitxsan and the Wet’suwet’en, to be in the strongest position of anyone in the province of actually completing the title question,” he said.

But chief negotiator Gwaans (Beverley Clifton-Percival) from the Gitxsan Hereditary Chiefs, which represents many but not all hereditary chiefs, said the Delgamuukw case was the best legal basis on which to launch a claim.

Gwaans, who is also the negotiator for the Gitxsan Treaty Society, said the GHC was unique to other First Nations groups.

“The public must understand that the Tsilhqot’in case is a band council case and not founded on a hereditary system,” she said.

“As well, the Tsilhqot’in case relied on the principles from the Gitxsan case to establish title.

“As a result, the legal test for title and rights in the Delgamuukw case is still what the Gitxsan will rely on, not the Tsilhqot’in case.

Although Gwaans said it would be a huge undertaking to recommence the land rights claim that was initiated through the Delgamuukw case, she added leaders were ready for a “new challenge.”

“Some of the lawyers are retired,” she said.

“The main witnesses for the Gitxsan has passed on and some of the chiefs now rely on band councils as their strength, ie. the Spookw plaintiffs.

“However, the earlier Simgiigyet paved the way and new leaders are ready for any new challenge as the inheritance laws through the Gitxsan mother is still strong.”

A representative of the Office of the Wet’suwet’en did not return this newspaper’s calls.

Lawyers Louise Mandell and Bertha Johnson could not be reached.


Just Posted

Telkwa council cautiously vigilant on crime stats

Crime severity was up, but reporting changes may be the cause, mayor says

July 2019 for Smithers “almost record breaking” says climatologist

David Phillips could only find one year with both more total precipitation and number of wet days

All Nations Driving Academy gets $360K boost from province

Terrace-based driving school bridges gap in services for remote northwest B.C. communities

VIDEO and PHOTOS: Thursday at the Spirit of the North Classical Music Festival

A brass fanfare, Classics on Main and a family folk dance were among the events on Day 2 of the fest

Skeena Watershed reopened for recreational pink and coho

Four sections and tributaries remain closed

VIDEO: Canadian zoos’ captive breeding programs help preserve endangered species

Programs considered last-ditch effort to prevent local extinctions of turtles, butterflies and more

B.C. sets rules for ride hailing, same minimum fee as taxis

Larger operating areas seen as threat by cab companies

Two hiking families team up to extinguish fire in B.C. backcountry

Children and their parents worked for three hours to ensure safety of the popular hiking region

Vancouver man arrested after pregnant woman’s SUV stolen, then crashed

Police are recommending charges against a 22-year-old Vancouver man

Elections Canada to assess ‘partisan’ climate change rhetoric case by case

People’s Party of Canada Leader Maxime Bernier has said climate change is not an emergency nor caused by human

Unseasonable snow forces campers out of northeastern B.C. provincial park

Storm brought as much as 35 centimetres of snow to the Fort Nelson, Muncho Lake Park-Stone Mountain Park

Telus customers enraged as outrage hits fifth day has been down since Aug. 15

B.C. log export rules killing us, northwest harvester says

NorthPac Forestry says Skeena Sawmills has plenty of timber

Search crews find 4-year-old boy who went missing near Mackenzie

George went missing early Saturday afternoon

Most Read